Apple Watch Review
Introduction
A week ago, I received an Apple Watch (Sport) as a graduation gift. Given the curiosity and the hype surrounding the device, I decided to write a review of the watch based on my initial impressions of its usefulness. I wore the watch every day for the past week. In brief, I have found that this edition of the watch is subtly useful and aesthetically pleasing, but ultimately redundant due to its total reliance on the iPhone for nearly all of its applications. The watch has no Wi-Fi or data connectivity and so all the information it receives is derived from the iPhone’s internet connection. All of the apps on the watch so far have to be pre-installed on the iPhone first and of course not every iPhone app is compatible with the watch. You can’t type anything on the watch face, so using Siri is a must if you want to send messages or look up directions. Notwithstanding its value as a fashionable status symbol, it is basically an expensive iPhone accessory on a much smaller screen which in all likelihood will cost you more than the iPhone itself if you choose to buy anything fancier than the cheapest model ($350). As such I would recommend that the majority of prospective buyers wait until a new Watch is released with more independent functionality, Wi-Fi connectivity, and exclusive, made-for-Watch apps.
Pros
To me the Apple Watch’s greatest strength is its aesthetic value and versatility. The watch case looks sleek, clean, polished, and well-made. The screen itself has a Retina display so it matches the display quality of the iPhone 6. The bands are interchangeable, which is another nice touch, although fancier bands can be quite expensive. The Sport edition comes with a sport band in white (pictured here), black, or fluorescent red/blue/green. So if you have a Sport and you bought a more luxurious band, like the Milanese loop, then you could switch out the bands depending on the formality of the occasion. The watch face itself comes 38mm and 42mm editions, in aluminum, stainless steel, or gold. I’m sure you have heard about the ridiculously expensive gold editions- suffice it to say, if you have the money to buy a gold edition watch you are probably not reading this review. The stainless steel face definitely looks better than the aluminum one, which I presently own, but it costs $200 more. The actual hardware that you would be purchasing is identical in the Sport and the most expensive gold edition. All in all the watch is an intriguing fashion accessory which could conceivably be used in conjunction with a variety of outfits and settings, ranging from casual to semiformal to formal.
On the side of the watch, there is a “crown” scroll/button along with a side button. The crown is basically a home button insofar as pressing it turns on the screen and it brings you to the “home page,” which is an interesting honeycomb design of circle-shaped app icons that resembles the applications dock in a Macbook. You can also just press on the screen, or raise your wrist a few inches, to wake the watch from “sleep” mode. Lowering your wrist or a few seconds of inactivity puts the watch back to sleep. I found it pretty cool that the watch responded to the motion of my wrist, although it’s not always instantaneous. You can swipe up and down on the screen to quickly view certain apps such as the weather, the stock market, event calendar, and of course the watch face. There are about ten watch faces you can choose from, ranging from a standard digital watch face to a Mickey Mouse face. I prefer the “motion” watch face, pictured here, which shows a succession of butterflies flapping their wings.
Battery life is about a twelve hours depending on how much you use it and what you use it for. It’s not nearly as much of a problem as I initially anticipated. Only a few years ago, I was using a “dumb phone” that didn’t need to be charged for a week. After getting a smart phone, I got into the habit of charging it once a day before I went to bed. The same goes for the watch. It’s really not that much more inconvenient to plug the watch into the charger after plugging in the iPhone.
To me, the watch is good at two things: “screening out” notifications that might have otherwise incessantly clogged up your attention coming from your iPhone, and providing a quick way for you to access information that might otherwise be cumbersome to check on the iPhone. Let’s say you’re in a business meeting, where it would be inconvenient and rude to pull out your smartphone to check your email or respond to a notification unless it was of absolute importance. The watch would enable you to quickly screen out all the silly notifications, Facebook updates and the like which are unimportant and not worth excusing yourself from the meeting to read. If you receive a text and you see on the watch that it’s quite important, then you can attend to that and notify your colleagues that you have an important message to respond to. Of course it’s arguable that constantly looking at your watch isn’t any more socially acceptable than constantly checking your phone. In this day and age, it’s almost a given that a smart phone will on the table when you are at dinner or meeting a friend. And it’s not advisable to draft important emails on the watch given Siri’s unreliability. But I can still imagine social scenarios where pulling out your smart phone would be rude and unnecessary, and the watch can help minimize the frequency of those scenarios. It seems counterintuitive that adding more screens would help you pay attention to your surroundings, but I think in certain contexts it does work. When I wear my watch I’m less tempted to just lay my iPhone on a table and wait for it to notify me with trite or mundane updates. I glance at the watch, then return to my activity if the notification is unimportant, which it almost always is. When I’m on my iPhone I’m liable to waste hours on clickbait after ostensibly “checking my notifications.” From my experience, the watch helps to eliminate some of that impulse.
I don’t normally wear a watch so of course wearing the Apple watch means I don’t have to pull out my phone to check the time, which I used to do frequently. I also can use the watch to quickly check the weather forecast and my calendar. For some apps, like Shazam or the Activity Fitness app, it’s also more convenient to just tap on the watch and activate the app rather than pull out the phone to do the same thing. If I was jogging, or otherwise wanted to keep my hands free, the watch enables you to check your progress, heart rate, change the song while listening to music, etc. without having to pause and pull out your phone. Of course I see plenty of people on the street wearing their phones on their arms using armbands to accomplish basically the same effect.
Wearing the watch is interesting. Invariably some people notice the watch and ask you about it. I’m acutely aware of the fact that I will probably never run into another Watch owner whenever I step outside, considering that it’s still not that popular of a device. This is amusing considering how ubiquitous Apple devices are otherwise. Owning an iPhone almost has no significance anymore because they’re so prevalent in all segments of the population. But owning a watch, especially at this early stage, does mean something. Whether or not that’s something you want to be associated with is another matter. For me it’s a positive because I like to be different and I like the fact that smart watches and wearable tech in general hasn’t really caught on yet among the general populace.
Cons
It’s redundant. There’s no point checking Instagram or Maps on your watch, squinting to see the tiny screen, when you can do the same thing on the much larger iPhone 6. The same goes with any picture or image or message longer than a few sentences. Considering that the watch isn’t usable without the phone anyway, it’s guaranteed that the phone would be in your pocket at the time you are contemplating using the watch for the same function. And there are very few instances where the inconvenience of pulling out your phone outweighs the inconvenience of trying to use the watch to accomplish a task that is in almost every case better suited for the phone.
I would say your comfort and familiarity with Siri plays a big role. If you’re already used to using Siri to check for directions or to look up restaurant recommendations or the like, then I can see how using the watch makes sense because it’s more convenient to talk into the watch than to pull out your phone. But if you don’t use Siri very often then it’s not going to make sense to talk into your watch when you can just type in your query into your phone in a few seconds. In any case the time you save by using your watch rather than your phone for most functions is unlikely to be more than a few seconds at most.
Using the watch a lot burns battery on the phone. I’ve found that my iPhone battery life has gotten worse the more I use the watch. It makes sense because everything the watch does is derived from the phone. It’s not to the point where I need to charge the phone twice a day but it is noticeable.
There are only a handful of customizable watch faces, which is a bummer. I was hoping to have a lot of different faces that appealed to different styles and interests.
The watch has no headphone jack. If you want to listen to music you’ll be listening to earphones plugged into the phone (which you can control with the watch), or you’ll be listening to Bluetooth headphones if your phone is off. The watch can only hold a few hundred songs though.
It’s expensive. Most of the functions you’ll actually use the watch for are available on a FitBit or a Pebble for a fraction of the cost.
It’s geeky, especially if you end up using Siri a lot and talking into your watch or tapping away at your watch face in the middle of the street. Although this could very well change if everybody gets a smart watch.
The biggest con is it’s new and it’s the first generation, so the watch will undoubtedly improve a lot in the years to come. Compare the first iPhone to the iPhone 6 and it’s a world of difference. The same should apply for the watch. Also, it’s possible that the smart watch trend in general could fizzle out. Does anyone still have iPods?
Conclusion
I recommend that the majority of consumers wait until the new watch comes out to see if the new edition will be more independent and autonomous from the iPhone. It would also be nice if the price tag was reduced to more reasonable levels considering its status as a glorified iPhone accessory.
